Oh, Christian Forums.....
Oh, I've dealt with SO much wrong, gross injustice, hate from senior staffers at CF over the 10 years or so, the tens of thousands of posts I had there..... And (perhaps because of my youth at the time), I had a LOT of pain as a result of the gross mistreatment.
1. After 3 staffers twisted my arm to come on staff (over 10 years ago), I applied. Then the whole staff had to vote for applicants. I was accepted, 23 to 0. Even though, I was "known" (in those days) as one who was struggling with Catholicism (I was still officially Catholic I think at that point) and with Mormonism (which I was studying at that point) and had a reputation for saying what was in my heart... for frankness and honesty. 23 to Zero. Because I got associated with some powerbrokers (unfortunately), I rocketed and within a few weeks was one of the few supervisors and participating in a lot of decisions, STRONGLY passionate about keeping CF an open, respectful community of bridges.... encouraging discussion. All new staffers had an official mentor, and mine was very active, strongly encouraging me, supporting me, telling me constantly what a great staffer I was and how helpful I was. Being stupid, I often worked TWENTY hours a week or more just on staffing stuff, often doing things others didn't want to do. Training, cleaning up, dealing with staffers who didn't play well together, etc. Then..... one day out of the blue..... I got fired. NOT by my Admin (who was FURIOUS that he had been circumvented and all protocol violated) but directly by the Executive Committee - the letter coming from MY MENTOR (who 2 weeks earlier said I was one of the best staffers at CF and if I had any problems, let him know). Reasons? He gave none.... said he didn't need any.... and told me to "take it like a man." I protested the COMPLETE, total violation of all protocol and demanded to at least know WHY. I was finally given 3 reasons..... one of which was an outright lie (which I noted as such), one was an issue I appealed AND WON, the other was simply a misunderstanding on my part for which I had PUBLICLY apologized and PUBLICALLY been forgiven for. It didn't matter. My mentor's reply for the Exec Committee, "you're not taking this like a man..... shut up, stop making waves or I'll issue a permanent ban on you." BTW, the firing was issued as a PERMANENT ban on me ever being on staff there, which is why I never could return to staff. BTW, years later, another member of that Exec Committee told me that I was "a sacrificial lamb" and was "________" because I was considered "disposable" and that my firing "satisfied some." He noted MANY higher than me got fired over the years also for doing nothing other than being among the best staffers at CF who "happen to be on the losing side of the war" at that moment. He told me, too, my mentor was "not happy" being told to fire me. But since then.... in the years since then..... those high up have been on my case.
2. Another of the MANY, MANY, MANY examples I could give. One day.... out of the blue..... an Advisor (one I had once helped out a lot when she was brand new) wrote me a PM informing me that while my record was clean (no warnings, no infractions), she was nonetheless issuing me a FSB (which didn't exist at that point) for one year. She stated she would not tell me why, and I was forbidden to ask why. And I was forbidden to tell any staffers or the owner about this and if I appealed it, she would permanently ban me. I had to keep this a secret for one year.... THEN she'd discuss all this and tell me why. Again..... I had NO warnings or infractions on my record. So, for one year - I essentially left CF. When the year was up, I wrote her, asking her to do as she pledged: to tell me WHY she issued that secret FSB and treated me as she did, and to "discuss" this. But she refused. She made the ban permanent and said she would NOT discuss it, she would NOT tell me why, I could NOT appeal it, I had to keep it a secret. I did not agree to that (theorizing she'd probably just permanently me - but she did not). That ban is still in place..... and there is still the insistence that as an Admin, she is above the rules, that there's no need to follow protocol, that her power is unmitigated, and I have to take it and shut up (at least I didn't get the "take it like a man" spell).
3. Just one more of the MANY, MANY examples I have. An Advisor (and one who had been a friend) STRESSED to me that now at CF, anything posted that one COULD CHOOSE to be offended by was now cause for an immediate ban - even if there was no violation of the rules. A couple of days later, he PUBLICLY (in a post).... BY NAME (specifically "CaliforniaJosiah")..... stated I was mentally ill. That's what he publically posted, I was "mentally ill" (he even labeled me with a specific mental illness). PUBICLY. BY NAME. But.... I soon learned..... it was all okay. HE could do this.... but if any poster said something NOT violating the rules.... but a reader CHOOSES to feel offended by it.... that poster gets an automatic two day ban. Just not Advisors. Over and over and over, for 10+ years, it has been STRESSED as an on-going montra, that senior staffers are all--powerful, can do whatever they want - even it seems PUBLICLY and BY NAME accuse posters of being "mentally ill." THAT gets no immediate two day ban because.....
I could go on and on and on and on...... SO many examples over the years. I have some stronger than the above that I can't share. There is a 'tude in the upper staff (well, among some) that is ugly and abusive. And the part that keeps pestering me is that generally, these are good people, people who once were considered friends, people with whom I've often worked and who often agree with me. There are issues at the top that are a mystery to me.... that seem to pollute good people. I've witnessed this in institutions.... but never more than at CF. I think it has greatly harmed CF and its ministry, and I know there are MANY, MANY, MANY good people who - one way or the other - have been booted out of CF. Sad to see.
I occasionally peak over there (lots of respected friends there)... but I confess.... EACH TIME, there is this sick, hurt feeling that returns to my heart. No hyperboli..... it hurts when I'm there. And that's why I'll never return. I've just been HURT so often, so badly.... not by posters, not my mods, but by Advisors and Admins - often by people I THOUGHT were friends, by people I respected. Over and over. The Judas kiss. And this I say with great personal embarrassment.... I kept coming back for more. I've learned my lesson.
- Josiah
.