Latest activity

I never said I agreed. My goal was to draw attention to the facts concerning what Athanasius actually did say verses what he clearly...

Ok. So you agree with him then that Esther is not scripture? Have you removed it from your Bible yet?

Are all the concepts in one book? it seems the logical carrier of this message is those Jews being scattered. Isaiah may talk of...

I went to the county park to hike this morning and then picked up my new glasses after lunch. They feel really cheap even though they...

I used to volunteer at our daughters school when she was young. Every day at a certain time (I think it was after lunch) there’d be a...

If you are going to say that "you heard" something, how about providing the source of your information such as a link. That way, we can...

It's really hard to say much about such a wide group of people. Chances are within any group you'll find some who will rush to get the...

Yes. Athanasius did not believe they were Scripture, but that does not mean he thought they were apocryphal.

Well, now you’re confusing me. Athanasius included Esther among the books of Judith, Tobit, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach. And he said that...

To be clear, are you speaking of a military attack or of a political disagreement?

Yes I did and I am correct. I never make such a claim. You are trying to mislead. There is no reason since you are wrong. That is...

You said that Athanasius did NOT claim Esther is apocryphal. And yet, now you’re agreeing that he said Esther is Apocryphal. Do you...

Please provide primary sources for these claims.

You are misrepresenting Athanasius. Athanasius makes it clear there are three groups of books. First, there are the canonical books...

Also, Athanasius includes Baruch among the canonical books. So, I guess anyone who accepts Athanasius’ instruction must insert Baruch...