- Joined
- Jun 12, 2015
- Messages
- 13,927
- Gender
- Male
- Religious Affiliation
- Lutheran
- Political Affiliation
- Conservative
- Marital Status
- Married
- Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
- Yes
Some thoughts.....
1. The Bible indicates that the Angels celebrated our Lord's birth. So did the Shepherds. So did the Wise Men. I find NOTHING in Scripture that clearly indicates that all these sinned and offended God by celebrating the Coming of Our Lord.
2. The Bible never records the EXACT DATE of His birth. While I'd not place too much importance on that, maybe it wasn't recorded because the DATE isn't what matters, the EVENT is what matters. The Shepherds.... the Angels.... the Wise Men celebrated the Birth of Our Lord, not a date.
3. No one has been able to determine the actual date to supply what God in Scripture did not. Frankly, some GUESSES seem plausible but since the point is not the DATE but the CHRIST, it just doesn't matter what DATE is the actual, technical anniversary.... the anniversary isn't the point, Christ is the point. Since no one has been able to pin down the actual anniversary date of His birth (as if that mattered), then any is as good as any other. We do know that early Christians celebrated that birth on a very wide variety of dates, but eventually uniformity was desired and a date was chosen in the 4th Century on which all agreed henceforth the celebration would happen - universally. NOT because it was determine this was the best guess as to the anniversary but simply for the sake of order and commonality.
4. If some think the Shepherds, Angels and Wise Men were sinful and detestable and condemnable for celebrating Jesus' birth - and therefore they won't celebrate it either, I say: Fine (their choice) But I disagree. If they can prove the actual anniversary date..... and present biblical evidence that we are commanded to celebrate it only on that date.... that's fine, too. But that hasn't happened in 2000 years and I doubt any are holding their breath.
5. If Christians REALLY want to get all upset and obsessed over something, maybe they'd be more useful if they spoke up against child abuse or war or the decline in the percentage of humans who identify themselves as Christians. Seems to ME there is a LONG LIST of things they could get upset about .... rather than joining with the Angels, Shepherds and Wise Men in celebrating the Coming of the Christ. But that's just me.
- Josiah
.
1. The Bible indicates that the Angels celebrated our Lord's birth. So did the Shepherds. So did the Wise Men. I find NOTHING in Scripture that clearly indicates that all these sinned and offended God by celebrating the Coming of Our Lord.
2. The Bible never records the EXACT DATE of His birth. While I'd not place too much importance on that, maybe it wasn't recorded because the DATE isn't what matters, the EVENT is what matters. The Shepherds.... the Angels.... the Wise Men celebrated the Birth of Our Lord, not a date.
3. No one has been able to determine the actual date to supply what God in Scripture did not. Frankly, some GUESSES seem plausible but since the point is not the DATE but the CHRIST, it just doesn't matter what DATE is the actual, technical anniversary.... the anniversary isn't the point, Christ is the point. Since no one has been able to pin down the actual anniversary date of His birth (as if that mattered), then any is as good as any other. We do know that early Christians celebrated that birth on a very wide variety of dates, but eventually uniformity was desired and a date was chosen in the 4th Century on which all agreed henceforth the celebration would happen - universally. NOT because it was determine this was the best guess as to the anniversary but simply for the sake of order and commonality.
4. If some think the Shepherds, Angels and Wise Men were sinful and detestable and condemnable for celebrating Jesus' birth - and therefore they won't celebrate it either, I say: Fine (their choice) But I disagree. If they can prove the actual anniversary date..... and present biblical evidence that we are commanded to celebrate it only on that date.... that's fine, too. But that hasn't happened in 2000 years and I doubt any are holding their breath.
5. If Christians REALLY want to get all upset and obsessed over something, maybe they'd be more useful if they spoke up against child abuse or war or the decline in the percentage of humans who identify themselves as Christians. Seems to ME there is a LONG LIST of things they could get upset about .... rather than joining with the Angels, Shepherds and Wise Men in celebrating the Coming of the Christ. But that's just me.
- Josiah
.