Search results

But God exists

Of course he’s not a creature. He’s uncreated. But God exists. So God himself would be one thing that exists that hasn’t been created.

God didn’t create himself. Wouldn’t that be one thing that exists that God didn’t create?

I take the early church seriously, and so should you.

Why would it be? This is a book revered by the early church, and declared by multiple early church councils to be scripture. So it’s a perfectly relevant question to know whether or not it contains mistakes.

You haven’t shown one single historical mistake. Either show a historical mistake or stop talking. Otherwise you’re just a troll.

Why don’t you just admit that you don’t know of any historical mistakes and stop talking?

Ok, so you’re not saying she murdered her husband? You’re changing your story and saying she murdered someone else now? Ok, who did she murder? Are you talking about the fact that she cut off the head of Holofernes? That guy was the enemy. She’s a hero for doing that. She SAVED her nation by...

Ok, so you think Judith murdered her husband. Why do you think that? Show me chapter and verse where it says that.

I’m asking you to show a historical mistake in Judith. And instead you are trolling me with wild and nonsensical accusations that Judith murdered her husband, with no basis for believing that. YOU are trolling.

Wait, what? Are you saying Judith murdered her husband? Where did you that idea? So, every widow who has a dead husband is suddenly a murderer now? Is that it?

Wait, what? Judith is historically mistaken because it’s a sin for a woman to let her husband die?

What’s that got to do with anything? Prove a historical mistake in the book of Judith.

She was. But she was a widow at the time the story takes place. How does this prove a historical mistake?

Focus on the Topic? Nobody here has shown me 1 single mistake in the book of Judith. YOU focus on the topic.

Don’t feed the troll

So, nobody here knows of any historical mistakes in the book of Judith?

How come nobody wants to answer this question?

Name 1 mistake in the book of Judith

Historical mistakes in Judith.