Just because Jeremiah uses the same phrase as was used to describe the initial formation of matter that would be shaped into the creation does not mean that there was a world that had to be destroyed prior to our current world being formed and populated. Formless and void is a state. It can be from a lump of clay that has not been made into a bowl yet, or it could be from clay that has been smashed and pulverized. There is nothing in the words for formless and void that would imply a destruction.
That's an assumption, and is not accurate. The Hebrew
tohu ("without form") is a Hebrew word that can apply to something in a good state going to a waste or nothing state (Job 6:18; Isaiah 29:21; Isaiah 40:23; Isaiah 45:18 where God said He did not create the earth
tohu).
But let's pretend there is this "gap." Then how long was it from Genesis 1:1 to Genesis 1:2?
No one knows how long that time gap was. But the fossil record, the true fossil record, does reveal a destruction ended a much more ancient time on earth, and destroyed various specie of God's original creation that have never appeared in today's present creation, i.e., like dinosaurs and the woolly mammoth. Then a period existed in the fossil record where no life existed, and then suddenly a springing forth of new life of the species of today's world.
And about one of the woolly mammoth found in the Arctic region, buried frozen in the ice. It still had plant vegetation in its mouth showing it was caught grazing in a green field, and also plant vegetation undigested in its stomach. That still puzzles scientists, because that points that it was caught in the Arctic which was not yet ice, but lush and green. And then suddenly the mammoth was instantly buried in a flood of water that also instantly froze. Otherwise, unfrozen waters would have decayed the mammoth instead of preserving it in the fresh state when it died.
Also not widely made known, is the fact that both the earth's poles have fossil remains of tropical plant and animal life.
Scientists like to think the earth's land plates shifted, to try and explain that; like the land at the poles was at one time located in warmer regions of the earth, but that idea has never been proven.
What was created in 1:1 that was then destroyed?
God's PERFECT CREATION.
Revelation 21:1 that says in the world to come there will be no more sea (i.e.,. no more oceans), that reveals what? A brand new creation of a brand new earth, as if this present earth will be totally destroyed, and then God will start afresh? No, because God didn't literally turn the ancient earth into an asteroid belt either when He brought a flood upon it to end Satan's original time of rebellion against Him.
So where are all those ocean waters going to go, think kind in the natural sense based on the Scriptures? Well, He gave us the view in Genesis 1:2-9 of a time of previous waters overspread upon this earth that He moved portions of it to create today's sky atmosphere around the earth. The rest of those waters He left upon the earth, and then moved those around on the earth until the dry land appeared. All that is not difficult to understand IF... one reads it as written without men's preconceived traditions affecting it.
So what's wrong with today's sky atmosphere around the earth today? I know, most think it is perfect and beautiful, which it is, kind of. However, it may be beautiful, as God's creation is, but it is not perfect, which is why Paul showed in Romans 8:18-25 that God placed His creation in bondage to corruption for this present world time.
The problem with today's sky around the earth is that it is full of holes. This is what actually causes our violent storms for this present world time. Cold air from the heights is heavier and falls down to mix with warmer air at the surface that is rising, because of the sun shinning through those sky holes to heat the earth and evaporate waters upon the earth. That mix in the sky is what causes violent storms, along with the water vapor rising to fill up those clouds and turn them 'black' as rain clouds.
But what would happen if all... of those holes in today's sky were filled by the ocean waters on today's earth? It would form a complete cloud canopy around the earth, and be like a greenhouse. In a greenhouse, the temperature is the same everywhere in it. Thus it would be like a tropical paradise all over the earth, not more desert hot regions at the equator, no extreme cold regions at the poles, just like the real ancient fossil record shows.