No, it's not. It merely means that you are a member (in addition to receiving the benefits that any sacrament brings). A church member certainly can wind up in hell.
I think that he meant the institutional church, but that was before there were the denominations that later developed. He, as a Catholic, probably did have in mind the Roman Catholic Church since that church insists that the one founded by Christ was the RCC and that all others stemmed off from it later on.
Yes, I would agree. However I would have to add that Scripture teaches that we all are expected to be part of a visible church and are not in accord with the Lord's instructions if we choose not to do that.
That doesn't make the church inoperable, you know. And you cannot replace what the visible church does if you 'go it alone.'
Yes, okay, and I dont think we're in as much disagreement as it first seemed.
(See what can happen when even a couple of knuckleheads ... strike that ... intellygent persons ... can accomplish if they stick with it and dont run from a little debate?
Like Jesus said, let's reason together, tho I know I just violated my own position of not taking an isolated verse out of context, but the idea's the same ... I dont think we're aiming for different results, ultimately, the way say a staunch atheist/evolutionist would be arguing with a christian/creationist, per se)
But we still have different views, or at least definitions, about 'church membership'.
I did say that some church (visible) members are not necessarily saved, and you seemed to disagree at first, but then agreed by saying they could wind up in hell.
So, yes, then theyre not saved. Thats what I was saying.
But I still say that scripture says 'the church' is the body of Christ, and we dont join that, but are born into it. When we believe in Jesus, we're saved, born again, born from above, and we are members of the body of Christ ... the church.
And thats the church I was referring to when I said 'being saved is synonymous with being a member of the church'.
As far as benefits from sacraments and things, thats a separate issue, and becomes a denominational opinion we dont need to expound here.
Yes, we should be participants in a local body of believers if possible (as it says in that great book of Hebrews)(yay osas lol)
But ... Its not always possible for everyone, and just because theyre not or dont participate in certain ceremonies doesnt make them any less a christian.
If a person is saved, theyre saved, and a member of Gods church, there is no more condemnation, and nothing can separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord. How I wish everyone could see that, see how much Jesus loves us.
Oh, and if you only knew RIGHT NOW how I wish some ppl could see that, and the condemnation would stop.
I cant elaborate, but Man, I keep getting stabbed in the heart and the back at the same time, and it really really hurts.