• Welcome to Christianity Haven, thank you for visiting! If you have not already, we invite you to create an account and join in on the many discussions we have! 

    • Please be aware that when registering you must not register while using a VPN. Any registrations made using a VPN will be rejected.
    • Additionally, registration emails are not being sent out which is an issue that is being worked on. Your registration may go into an approval queue for admin approval. We work to send manual emails to the email on file, so please ensure the email you use is one you can readily access! 

How Socialism Violates All Ten Commandments

Frankj

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2024
Messages
1,167
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Non-Denominational
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Honestly, my wife has her own charity. I help work with her on it. I even give funding we help 100s of children in poverty with clothes, school funding and food both in the US and Nigeria. I can DM you my wife charity its on Instagram, facebook, etc.

I also help volunteer at a church here with my time. Giving out food to those in need.

What may you do yourself to serve as God commands us, friend?

I do appreciate you acknowledging my points though with this response. :)
That's commendable (assuming your charity doesn't operate off of government money) and is something few can say.

Buy why then do you advocate using government to take away from the productive and give the proceeds of their work to those who did not work for it?

Wouldn't it be better to advocate for the Churches and other private persons to step up and do it instead?

Consider the lives and teachings of William and Catherine Booth who worked through the Church and never put God in second place to further their efforts. (Socialism always puts God in second place, often to the extent of outlawing and persecuting those who don't)
 

Frankj

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2024
Messages
1,167
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Non-Denominational
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
I think you are on the wrong premise or not understanding. If you are worried about government taking your resources, are we referring to objects or taxation? Taxation is a given, which taxes are used for social programs, etc. Issue with current system is Government strips social programs like social security to fund other things like war. Social security was proven effective because elderly today would have had no safety net, poverty rates would be double and mostly elderly without it because Americans have nasty habit of never saving.

Secondly, if you are concerned about your taxes being used to support those in need, what would you prefer it for? As I said lot of people are suffering, the church is only so large and not everyone believes as it clearly shown to be charitable. So should we allow suffering or should something be done about it? As many right leaning individuals love to say the US was founded on Christian principles the wording is literal, the government by design and intention was to serve common man and uplift people, which is does not. We no longer have war on poverty, more so now we support more poverty and suffering than other way around. If I am using the scriptures incorrectly, when I walk next to a poor person would it be better I ignore his plight and tell him to get right with God to improve his situation or take action to help uplift him? Faith without works is dead, I believe firmly we should have a government system that designed around uplifting than downtrodden those less fortunate.

Which kind of system do you think Jesus would desire? Who were type of people he spent time mostly with?
The government operates on government money, bringing unwanted indebtedness to those it taxes to fund its borrowing (currently around a trillion a year in interest on the federal level alone). This is not sustainable. When it crashes either through default of payments or hyperinflation to pay it of with near worthless money, almost everyone will end up poor and there will be no money to pay for all those social programs that rewarded non productivity and caused it to start with.

So what does the bible say about what should be done with those who produce and those who don't produce but live off of the productivity of others?
 

Player One

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
11
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
That's commendable (assuming your charity doesn't operate off of government money) and is something few can say.

Buy why then do you advocate using government to take away from the productive and give the proceeds of their work to those who did not work for it?

Wouldn't it be better to advocate for the Churches and other private persons to step up and do it instead?

Consider the lives and teachings of William and Catherine Booth who worked through the Church and never put God in second place to further their efforts. (Socialism always puts God in second place, often to the extent of outlawing and persecuting those who don't)

No government money, self funding or through volunteer work and donations.

Thing is God law and Human law will never co-exist no matter the system. Its simply trying to do what's best. Remember God never desired for us to have kings, he only wanted to have him. Story of Saul is a good example why, even David and Solomon had flaws.

I think we focus too much on what socialism can be in certain sections and parts. I have debated lots of democratic socialists, the mass majority of them do not advocate for taking things from others. They want a revamp of taxation system and use it more towards people vs most things its used for. Spend more money on education, Healthcare, subsidies, etc.

Its easy to get into and assume worse out of each system, there is a lot of flaws between the big 3. America was suppose to be a melting pot of different ideas and be our own thing. Not capitalist, socialist or communist. We focus too much on the idea that because a idea like Medicare for all, even though its a tax based pool system healthcare like how businesses pool healthcare instead it would be government is a bad thing, when it is the opposite. It is not taking anything that is not already there, also reduces cost of healthcare. This is just one example.
 

Frankj

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2024
Messages
1,167
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Non-Denominational
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
No government money, self funding or through volunteer work and donations.

Thing is God law and Human law will never co-exist no matter the system. Its simply trying to do what's best. Remember God never desired for us to have kings, he only wanted to have him. Story of Saul is a good example why, even David and Solomon had flaws.

I think we focus too much on what socialism can be in certain sections and parts. I have debated lots of democratic socialists, the mass majority of them do not advocate for taking things from others. They want a revamp of taxation system and use it more towards people vs most things its used for. Spend more money on education, Healthcare, subsidies, etc.

Its easy to get into and assume worse out of each system, there is a lot of flaws between the big 3. America was suppose to be a melting pot of different ideas and be our own thing. Not capitalist, socialist or communist. We focus too much on the idea that because a idea like Medicare for all, even though its a tax based pool system healthcare like how businesses pool healthcare instead it would be government is a bad thing, when it is the opposite. It is not taking anything that is not already there, also reduces cost of healthcare. This is just one example.
FWIW, and sort of going in a different but specific direction, if you want to reduce the cost of healthcare you have to reduce the government mandated and caused control of it through its bureaucratic administrative structure which is a far greater cost than the cost of actual medical care which receives only a minor fraction of it.

This is a predictable result of government involvement in anything and a major reason socialism always fails amidst the human misery of enforced mediocracy it brings.

Don't look to man to govern himself in place of God governing him, something a guy named Adam learned the hard way.
 
Last edited:

Player One

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
11
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
The government operates on government money, bringing unwanted indebtedness to those it taxes to fund its borrowing (currently around a trillion a year in interest on the federal level alone). This is not sustainable. When it crashes either through default of payments or hyperinflation to pay it of with near worthless money, almost everyone will end up poor and there will be no money to pay for all those social programs that rewarded non productivity and caused it to start with.

So what does the bible say about what should be done with those who produce and those who don't produce but live off of the productivity of others?

Well we will always have people that do not produce, elderly who we are commanded to respect and take care of. Once they reach certain age they retire. As a statistics there is suppose to be 2 workers for every one elderly retiree to keep up with demands. Unfortunately even in the US that is getting worse, debt is how to US economy runs, if we paid off the debt the US economy will flatline we run off a debt based economy which is not right, but here we are.

Then there is also disabled. Also certain people who can not work for mental or other reasons, now yes there is genuine people who do not work because of laziness, but who are we to deny help to all because of a few? We can not judge a whole barrel of apples because of a few rotten ones. If that was the case God would been better off ending our species during the flood.
 

Player One

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
11
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
FWIW, and sort of going in a different but specific direction, if you want to reduce the cost of healthcare you have to reduce the government mandated and caused control of it through its bureaucratic administrative structure which is a far greater cost than the cost of actual medical care which receives only a minor fraction of it.

This is a predictable result of government involvement in anything and a major reason socialism always fails amidst the human misery of enforced mediocracy it brings.

Don't look to man to govern himself in place of God governing him, something a guy named Adam learned the hard way.

Funny enough government is not issue for high healthcare cost. Its more of big pharma greed. How do I know this? Goldman Sach said it himself, there is no profit in curing people. Healthcare is a profiteering racket than actual healthcare. Quality of life and healthcare cost is x10 lower in other countries like Sweden, Japan, Canada, etc. Cost for same medicine is x10 lower with even stricter regulation. US last time I checked ranks 38 in healthcafe while Japan, France, Germany, Sweden are in the top 10. Issue is not quality control, the issue is green control. Americans have been deceived that in order for us to get quality healthcare we have to spend more than everyone else, but we actually receiving the same if not worse than other countries. Even our own politicians go to other countries and do not want our own due to the cost.
 

Frankj

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2024
Messages
1,167
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Non-Denominational
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Well we will always have people that do not produce, elderly who we are commanded to respect and take care of. Once they reach certain age they retire. As a statistics there is suppose to be 2 workers for every one elderly retiree to keep up with demands. Unfortunately even in the US that is getting worse, debt is how to US economy runs, if we paid off the debt the US economy will flatline we run off a debt based economy which is not right, but here we are.

Then there is also disabled. Also certain people who can not work for mental or other reasons, now yes there is genuine people who do not work because of laziness, but who are we to deny help to all because of a few? We can not judge a whole barrel of apples because of a few rotten ones. If that was the case God would been better off ending our species during the flood.
Is there anyone stopping you from helping anyone you want to help?

Socialism is about forcing people, not having them volunteer.

Which leads to all sorts of conflict among people that eventually, and usually, results in failure and the rise of Tyranny in its place.

Good intentions need to be mitigated by an understanding of human nature as God created us and which can be found in the Bible if it is studied in depth. God created free will, socialism attempts to take it away.

You don't have to believe me, you're still young and can simply watch it happen as it happens.
 

Player One

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
11
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Is there anyone stopping you from helping anyone you want to help?

Socialism is about forcing people, not having them volunteer.

Which leads to all sorts of conflict among people that eventually, and usually, results in failure and the rise of Tyranny in its place.

Good intentions need to be mitigated by an understanding of human nature as God created us and which can be found in the Bible if it is studied in depth. God created free will, socialism attempts to take it away.

You don't have to believe me, you're still young and can simply watch it happen as it happens.

I am 33 years old, thanks.

Not all socialism is forced if that was true. Canada, Germany, Sweden would be pretty awful places. I actually traveled to Canada and Nigeria.

Politics is over expanding amount of ideas. Like democratic socialism, libertarianism, conservatism, etc. I personally do not believe people should suffer for sake of religious dogma in order to believe in God. Christ mocked people like the religious leaders of his time calling them hypocrites, how they claim to help people but always dressed themselves outwardly beautiful, but actually servants of Satan. This is what most of the church has dissolved into, more theatrical and less focused on what Christ calls us for.

How many Christians sit in pews, but never preach the gospel to their fellow employees or neighbors. How many had opportunities to help, but turned a blind eye. How many Christians preach to others yet do not live the same lives? People watch this people are not ignorant of what Christ stands for. What Christianity has failed to realize that even sinners want a world that Christ asks us for me and they sound socialism as the answer, because it offers healthcare, free educations, bringing back the war on poverty, uplifting people. Yet people like yourself want to call such ideas evil under dogma, while refusing to see the surface of what people are crying out for. When the church abandoned the world for a pew and thinks it is having victory listening to the same preacher every sunday. The world decided to use the very teachings of Christ against us.

Instead of acknowledging the fault we are making the same mistakes as Pharisee did during Christ time. While being so righteous, we ignore the plight of others. I believe fully most of the church will be condemned for this because that's what Christ put in my heart and showed me.

What will keep people out of heaven is this.

Unforgiving heart
Lack of heart for the least of us
Lack of accountability
Lack of a giving heart and servitude
Lack of surrendering ourselves to his will, and building treasures in heaven and instead in this world

This is why I believe way we do. We focus to much on our own desires, not on the desires of everyone else. Christ has grace on us all, why can't we show the same to everyone else?
 

Frankj

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2024
Messages
1,167
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Non-Denominational
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
I personally do not believe people should suffer for sake of religious dogma in order to believe in God.
Are able to support that belief with Biblical reference?

Jesus made it pretty clear that is what is going to happen, I doubt that either your or my beliefs factor into that truth.

Not all socialism is forced if that was true. Canada, Germany, Sweden would be pretty awful places. I

the problem there is that all three of them are financed by a capitalist economic system, and you might want to take a closer look at what is really going on there today (it's not what the MSM want you to believe is).

Men don't generally choose evil because it is evil, they choose it because they mistake it for happiness.

That goes all the way back to the garden.
 

tango

... and you shall live ...
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
15,540
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
I think you are on the wrong premise or not understanding. If you are worried about government taking your resources, are we referring to objects or taxation? Taxation is a given, which taxes are used for social programs, etc. Issue with current system is Government strips social programs like social security to fund other things like war. Social security was proven effective because elderly today would have had no safety net, poverty rates would be double and mostly elderly without it because Americans have nasty habit of never saving.

Certain things do need to be funded by taxation.

It's all well and good to say that people have a habit of not saving, but when did it become the government's job to rescue people from the consequences of their own decisions? And of course if taxes were lower it would be easier to save in the first place, no?

Secondly, if you are concerned about your taxes being used to support those in need, what would you prefer it for? As I said lot of people are suffering, the church is only so large and not everyone believes as it clearly shown to be charitable. So should we allow suffering or should something be done about it? As many right leaning individuals love to say the US was founded on Christian principles the wording is literal, the government by design and intention was to serve common man and uplift people, which is does not. We no longer have war on poverty, more so now we support more poverty and suffering than other way around. If I am using the scriptures incorrectly, when I walk next to a poor person would it be better I ignore his plight and tell him to get right with God to improve his situation or take action to help uplift him? Faith without works is dead, I believe firmly we should have a government system that designed around uplifting than downtrodden those less fortunate.

You present false dichotomies here. Should we allow suffering or should something be done? At some point we have to accept that suffering will exist. And whether "something should be done" isn't a simple question with a nice binary yes or no answer. When we ask if something should be done, we once again come back to the question of whether government should get to decide what counts as a worthy cause and take the fruit of my labor by force, thereby denying me the chance to direct that portion of my labor to what I consider a worthy cause. This is ironic, given your earlier comment abour government stripping social security to fund wars, which sits rather uneasily against your apparent lack of concern for governments stripping what I consider to be a worthy cause to fund what it considers to be a worthy cause.

Which kind of system do you think Jesus would desire? Who were type of people he spent time mostly with?

I think Jesus would promote a libertarian system. Pretty much everything in the Bible is a collection of instructions, paired with the freedom to obey or disobey as we choose. "If you love me, obey my commandments" is about as libertarian as it gets. No compulsion, no requirements, no coercion, just an invitation to follow in Christ's footsteps if we choose to do so.

Who Jesus spent time with isn't really the issue - even in his own parables we can look at the Good Samaritan. He saw the man who needed help and he voted for more social programs to help the victims of street violence. No, wait, that's not it. He wrote to his Congressman demanding more action to make the streets safer. No, hang on.... he posted on social media demanding that The Rich pay more taxes to make sure this sort of thing doesn't happen. Still wrong? Ah yes, he offered help there and then, using his own resources, without demanding anything from anyone else. Not exactly the socialist utopia people talk about as if Jesus were in favor....
 

tango

... and you shall live ...
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
15,540
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Then there is also disabled. Also certain people who can not work for mental or other reasons, now yes there is genuine people who do not work because of laziness, but who are we to deny help to all because of a few? We can not judge a whole barrel of apples because of a few rotten ones. If that was the case God would been better off ending our species during the flood.

This is where local systems are better than remote systems. All a remote system can do is assess a claim, assign it a value in dollars and cents, and hand out checks to those deemed deserving. Along the way it creates a perverse incentive for people to exaggerate their conditions, and creates a system where it can be more profitable to feign disability and collect the welfare checks than to work.

A local system doesn't create loopholes and reduces the opportunities to take advantage of the system. Another drawback of government-funded systems is that welfare becomes a means of gaining votes. Even the disaster that is the (un)affordable care act creates opportunities for scaremongering - the price of health insurance skyrockets because of government mandates, so the government takes from everybody to subsidise the increase that the government caused, thereby removing any incentive for the insurance companies to keep their prices down. And for good measure one party gets to scream that the other party will take away the subsidies, thereby making the unaffordable premiums, you know, unaffordable. So the solution is to hike the prices, then throw taxpayer money at it, while screaming that the other side will take it all away again.

The solution to too much government generally isn't more government, but that's what we get these days.
 

jswauto

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2025
Messages
1,212
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Socialism always fails because:
✔ not just because of bad leaders
✔ It fails because of its internal logic
✔ It requires force to maintain control
✔ It inevitably suppresses free will
✔ It stands in direct conflict with human dignity and moral agency
Christian principles are about free will, moral agency, and obedience to the Lord.
Socialist Regimes are the Antithesis of That.

When a government:​

1. Abolishes private property
2. Controls all production and distribution
3. Eliminates political opposition
4. Centralizes power in a single party
5. Controls speech, press, and assembly
It must use force to maintain control.
Because:

• People resist losing property
• Farmers resist quotas
• Workers resist forced labor
• Citizens resist censorship
• Minorities resist ideological conformity
So the system requires coercion to function.
That’s why every socialist regime — even the “mild” ones — ends up with:

• secret police
• political prisons
• censorship
• forced labor
• purges
• famine
• mass surveillance

⭐ LET’S LOOK AT THE USUAL “EXCEPTIONS” PEOPLE CLAIM AS SOCIALIST​

And why they don’t actually qualify:
1. Sweden / Norway / Denmark
Often cited — but not socialist.
They are capitalist economies with high taxes and welfare programs.
Private property, private business, and markets remain intact.
They are not socialist regimes.
2. Israel’s early kibbutzim
Voluntary, small‑scale, and not state‑enforced.
Not a national socialist regime.
3. Kerala (India)
Left‑wing governance, but still within a capitalist democratic framework.
Not a socialist regime.
4. Costa Rica
Social programs, yes.
Socialism, no.
5. Tanzania (Ujamaa)
Attempted socialism → resulted in famine, forced villagization, and collapse.
6. Yugoslavia (Tito)
Less brutal than Stalin — but still:
• secret police
• political prisons
• suppression of dissent
• ethnic repression
Not peaceful.
7. Cuba
Repression, executions, political prisons, and mass exile.
8. Vietnam / Laos
Re‑education camps, executions, and ongoing repression.
9. Nicaragua (Sandinistas)
Civil war, repression, and authoritarianism.
10. Venezuela
Economic collapse, political repression, and state violence.
 
Last edited:

tango

... and you shall live ...
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
15,540
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
“The more people who are dependent on government handouts, the more votes the Left can depend on for an ever-expanding welfare state.” - Thomas Sowell
 

tango

... and you shall live ...
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
15,540
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
"The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money." - Margaret Thatcher
 

Player One

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
11
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Certain things do need to be funded by taxation.

It's all well and good to say that people have a habit of not saving, but when did it become the government's job to rescue people from the consequences of their own decisions? And of course if taxes were lower it would be easier to save in the first place, no?



You present false dichotomies here. Should we allow suffering or should something be done? At some point we have to accept that suffering will exist. And whether "something should be done" isn't a simple question with a nice binary yes or no answer. When we ask if something should be done, we once again come back to the question of whether government should get to decide what counts as a worthy cause and take the fruit of my labor by force, thereby denying me the chance to direct that portion of my labor to what I consider a worthy cause. This is ironic, given your earlier comment abour government stripping social security to fund wars, which sits rather uneasily against your apparent lack of concern for governments stripping what I consider to be a worthy cause to fund what it considers to be a worthy cause.



I think Jesus would promote a libertarian system. Pretty much everything in the Bible is a collection of instructions, paired with the freedom to obey or disobey as we choose. "If you love me, obey my commandments" is about as libertarian as it gets. No compulsion, no requirements, no coercion, just an invitation to follow in Christ's footsteps if we choose to do so.

Who Jesus spent time with isn't really the issue - even in his own parables we can look at the Good Samaritan. He saw the man who needed help and he voted for more social programs to help the victims of street violence. No, wait, that's not it. He wrote to his Congressman demanding more action to make the streets safer. No, hang on.... he posted on social media demanding that The Rich pay more taxes to make sure this sort of thing doesn't happen. Still wrong? Ah yes, he offered help there and then, using his own resources, without demanding anything from anyone else. Not exactly the socialist utopia people talk about as if Jesus were in favor....

"You present false dichotomies here."

Proverbs 19:17
Matthew 25:31–46

“Then he will say to those on his left, ‘Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. 42 For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, 43 I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.’
44 “They also will answer, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?’
45 “He will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.’
46“Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.”

Accepting suffering, and doing nothing about it is two different things. We accept reality it exists, but as Christ himself said those who ignore and do nothing about it will go away to eternal punishment. If I present false dichotomies, then I gladly do so along with Christ according to your own words. Christ was also accused as such for these messages by the pharisee's themselves. I take this with a badge of honor, because even Christ own words offended the comfort of those who are not doing anything already, or ignore the plight of others and don't want to take action to improve, uplift others out of their plights.

Once again my posts are not being read with any form of discernment. I never once purely advocated for socialism. I am referencing to parts or policies, may be helpful. As I said before American is a melting pot of ideas, as Christians we should support policies that uplift people.
 
Top Bottom