I love this site. And the way it is moderated.
I've posted at DOZENS of sites (several of which don't even exist anymore) since I was 10 years old. Often WAY, WAY too much. I posted as a child, a teen and now an adult; as a Catholic, a seeker and now a Lutheran; as single and now as married. I've only been technically, formally banned once. It was from CatholicAnswers. I never had ANY contact from the staff there - none. No warnings, no infractions, no actions at all - not even an email or PM. But one day, when I went there, a window popped up saying I was permanently banned. And found I could read but not post. This status was added to all my posts, and thus a field day of attacks began - my posts twisted, misquoted and I found myself being blasted and unable to respond. I contacted staff to find out why I was banned and to report the flames but for over a month, there was no responds at all. FINALLY, I got a reply. The Admin said that I had been reported several times and that all the reports were arbitrated in my favor - no violation had been made. But it was eventually decided by staff that I was "not contributing to the objectives of the site" (the exact words) and thus was banned. The Admin said I could appeal the ban, but I decided that would be silly. Now, I've been essentially asked to leave from a couple of others. And at "the website that shall not be named" (that many of us formerly or also post at), it was threatened several times (in each case, I had NO warnings or infractions!). I did recieve a "forum specific ban" ("fsb") from an Advisor - who refused repeatedly to tell me why, who admitted I had NO active warnings whatsoever, and admitted that actually forum specific bans didn't exist anymore. I was also told I had to keep the action a secret or I'd be permanently banned. And that the reason would not be told to me and if I continued to ask, I would be permanently banned. And if I appealed it, I would be permanently banned. There was this carrot: it would all expire in one year. So I pretty much left for the year. But when the year was up, the ban (and all the conditions around it) were renewed permanently. I tried to return anyway - under those conditions - but upper staff (Advisors) made that absurdly miserable and difficult, attacking me at every turn, often reminded that they could permanently ban me anytime they wanted. I gave up. I'm now here.
I like it here. I don't spend NEARLY as much time posting as I once did, however.
Thank you!
Pax
- Josiah