Politicians in Education

Cmdr Data

Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2019
Messages
6
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Other Church
Political Affiliation
Conservative
Marital Status
Married
I'm currently a teacher in West Virginia. Our state has recently made waves across the nation as, yet again, leading a unionized movement to fight politician's role within education. A large part of the arguing between the various parties came down to educational choice. The laws being proposed sought to allow charter schools and educational savings accounts for non-public school systems. Without getting into my own beliefs on the matter, I would like to pose a conversation around the role of politicians and their impact on education. For you, where is the line in policy creation? Should politicians have educational experience to make educational policy? What experts should be consulted? Do you think expert opinion should be ignored if the will of the people is strong enough?
 

Josiah

simul justus et peccator
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jun 12, 2015
Messages
13,927
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Lutheran
Political Affiliation
Conservative
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
Some thoughts....


1. "He who controls the purse controls everything." Public schools are funded 100% by politicians. It is therefore simply the reality that they will control what is done with that money - regardless of them knowing NOTHING about education.


2. Politicians are... well.... politicians. They are experts on the art of POWER. They seek to control society and they seek to control voters in such a way as to get re-elected. It's just what they do. This is easiest with the young as they formulate their political, moral and social ideas and philosophies. When they graduate from high school, they become voters. Their social, moral and political ideas - which hopefully they formed in large part from their education - will now be put into practice. When Alexander the Great expanded into new lands, his goal was to make them GREEKS in EVERYTHING (right down to dress and architecture). He skipped right over adults (too hard to change them) and focused on children..... he was the first in history to form public, state-funded, required education... to make them GREEKS. He knew in 20 years, he would succeed in making his empire a GREEK empire.


3. I live in the People's Republic of California, a wonderful state I deeply love, but it is a ONE -PARTY state and that party is extremely liberal (and with no counter-balance, gets more and more leftest every year). As a result, history books here are anti-American and stress how great are native Americans, illegal immigrants, LGBT etc.... "Health" education is mostly about how masturbation is a sacrament, how kids are probably gay and need encouragement to "come out" and how sex is just natural and as long as you cover things, it's wonderful. Since a lot of teachers are liberal democrats, they have allies. Now, SOME teachers (my wife was until this year) do their best to "lay aside" all the liberal JUNK (on the day they were to celebrate the Gay Pride flag, she and some other teachers taught and celebrated the AMERICAN flag - the principal just pretending he didn't notice).... she simply skipped nearly half of the "health" lessons and never taught them. The SAD THING IS.... parents don't care. Including Christian parents. They can "opt out" their kids from this junk but none do; they can come and view all the sex ed stuff for themselves but none do. No one protests this liberal brainwashing. And so it just gets worse and worse... and because time is taken away from reading and math to teach the glories of same-sex marriage, reading and math scores suffers - and teachers get blamed for that.


My son is going to go to a private, Christian school.



- Josiah
 

tango

... and you shall live ...
Valued Contributor
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
14,695
Location
Realms of chaos
Gender
Male
Religious Affiliation
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Acceptance of the Trinity & Nicene Creed
Yes
I forget who it was who said "give me a child until he is seven and he will be mine for life". That sums up why we shouldn't allow government to control education.

Some friends with children were recently explaining common core mathematics to me and how it allegedly works. My friend is an electronics engineer so it's not as if he's stupid where numbers are concerned but he struggles to help his 7-year-old with his homework because it's all done in a way that makes no sense any more. The best way I could sum it up is that it makes the most basic processes marginally easier while making the more advanced processes unimaginably harder. It's great to come up with ways to help the slowest kids in the class catch up but introducing weird and wondering schemes that hold the brightest back makes no sense at all.

If we could trust politicians to do what is right for children without looking to push their own agendas then I'd be less concerned. But frankly I don't trust politicians to do anything of the sort. I think government should be as far removed from education as possible.
 
Top Bottom